[Archive]

Posted By: Chris

Let me first say the scan was not a large clear one but I am certain the scan was not intentional with the seller as all the others look the same. Not the worse scan I have seen but not the best and it was difficult to see the name clearly. I am pretty sure it is trimmed because as I said half the name is cut off but the biggest thing is the 1/4 inch gap in the slab and it really does look sloped. The card was graded VG/EX so if it was possibly miscut, and I don't think it is, the grade is way off. I am sorry for not posting a scan or a link to the card but I got it from a fellow board member and out of respect to him I am giving him a chance to do what I feel is the right thing. I just felt this was a good topic to discuss. I know when I first started lurking on here there was a quite heated discussion between a couple of people( I don't remember who) about this very same thing. I tried to find that but couldn't. I personally would offer a full refund including shipping to a buyer if they were not happy for any reason. I would rather not take the chance of them being unhappy. Remember, there are those who complain to you and give you the cahnce to fix it, and there are those who just never buy from you again. I also do not feel like I am not without fault here as I guess I should have asked questions but I just don't want to email every seller about a cards condition.