Posted By:
Joe_G.I too am interested in this card but found a couple issues with the situation beyond what has already been mentioned. Most notably, the only other Old Judges he has are Anson & McCarthy (all his cards are HOFers). Also, most 1887 issued cards do not have that large of a border.
That is the last Brouthers pose I'd need so I may take a chance but I'm very skeptical.