Posted By:
jay behrensScott, I have a lot of respect for you and you are certainly more than knowledgable about baseball memoribilia, but your last post comes off as sounding like something from an eBay huckster looking to maximize their money on a questionable item. Just becuase you had 2 spirited bidders does not mean you had 2 knowledgable bidders. An item like this, if it truely is tied to the Newark Base Ball Club, would have generated some talk among the people in the 19c membership of SABR, but I have not seen anything mentioned.
Jay