Posted By:
slacksI agree with you.
The reality might be that the seller himself mistakenly paid too much for it and is trying to share the love.
Unfortunately, this guy posts a lot on the PSA boards and gives the impression of being pretty ethical. If he doesn't want to accept a return, it could get ugly for the buyer even if the buyer has the law on his side.
The buyer might have some recourse against PSA because the card is mislabelled.