Posted By:
runscott I have been trying to pin down accurate stats for Old Judge players, and it's a mess. The HOF, the Baseball Encyclopedia, Baseballreference.com and the Sports Illustrated site, ALL have different numbers!
Amos Rusie example: Sports Illustrated has him at 24-22 in 1895, Baseballreference.com has him at 23-23, the Baseball Encyclopedia has him at 29-8. And it's similar for other years in his career. The Baseball HOF site agrees almost exactly with the SI site, but has him at 12-14 in 1889, as opposed to 12-10 on SI. What a mess - anyone have an answer?