Posted By:
jay behrens"There doesn't seem to be paper loss, just some scuffing."
that's like a car dealer telling you there is no rust on the car, just some surface oxidation. Unless the card is a Peter's Meats issue or some other issue with a thick, waxy surface, it's impossible to scuff the surface of the card without creating some sort of paper loss.
If PSA really does grade like this on a consistant basis, then I have some SGC 40 and 50 cards that should pull 6s or better.
Jay