[Archive]

Posted By: Jay Miller

Bob--In answer to your questions as to whether I think I know more about Old Judge than SCG graders, GAI graders and Rhys--yes. You are correct, I did not see the card in person but I saw scans of it. We discussed the card on the board and not only myself, but Dan also I believe, mentioned the reprints that this card appeared to be part of. If you still had doubts in your mind did you contact someone else who was experienced in this area, perhaps Lew Lipset? Looks like you just listed it on ebay as this "mystery card". Am I correct that you also never mentioned in the write-up that there were questions about the cards authenticity, that it might be a reprint?
BTW, we all know that ebay's rating system is a joke. Short of outright fraud it is tough to get negative feedback from anyone. Also, the fact that I treaded close to ebay's bidder inteference "line" bothers me to no end.