Posted By:
Marc S.Jim:
The card is simply a variation card -- much different than say a Wagner card which is rare in its own right. The only thing that makes the Doyle variation rare is the NY Nat'l after his name. Many advances collectors do not get caught up in the variation game. And, honestly, at $60,000+, would you?
Also -- two of the main afficianados of the set who have the cash and desire to own this card already do.
Yes -- it may very well be one of the rarest variations from the T-206 set. But some will eventually argue what exactly constitutes a variation. What of the Murr'y "variation" that also sold in Mastro, for significantly less money.
Also -- remember that a card's value often has little to do with rarity. The game, story and prominence of the card often is just as important as its rarity. There are many E* and N* series cards that are often significantly rarer -- and sometimes to this day only know of a handful, if not one or two known examples. Rarity can often be but a small part of the equation.
Finally -- remember that this hobby can be exceptionally thinly traded after certain levels. We are all collectors and love the hobby, right? Well, we represent a small portion of the country (or the world...). Now, what percentage of collectors do you know that will spend $100 on a card? Most? Sure -- but that alienates a number of younger collectors. What about $1,000? How about $10,000? How many collectors do you personally know that will spend over $50,000 on a card -- a card that is "only" Very Good to boot?
Once you get into that upper echelon of collectors -- money and ego drive the game more than anything. Yes, a lower grade Doyle sold for three times more a few years back. But where was the third bidder on that auction? That is the key information in most circumstances.
I in no way want to take away from the importance of the card or its history (or lack thereof). I would say, however, that had I $60,000 to spend in the hobby, this would not be where I would spend it. Not even in my top 25 choices....
MS