[Archive]

Posted By: Dan Mathewson

So, is it possible that SGC overgraded this card? This has been an interesting topic to follow on this board, as I follow several of he conversations comparing the two services.

I constantly hear it stated that SGC grades tougher and more consistently than PSA does. And, that an SGC-5 is consistently a better quality card than a PSA-5 (and so on, up and down the scale...)

I've actually been curious to see if this is true, and I've kinda waited for a comparison like this to come up on eBay to check it out. I am curious about others' opinions...

(I haven't been on the board much lately, been traveling quite a bit, and I'm in Anchorage right now freezing my baseballs off...)



-dan