Posted By:
Albie O'Hanianrunscott-Probably a 7 or lower from all of the excess handling.
Really I think it would depend on the card and the individual grader. Grading is very subjective and there are a number of factors going into the grade of the card that are dependent strictly on that grader. I would like to believe that the card would come back with the same grade all 9 times - but I realize the reality of the situation and that it is very unlikely. I have seen plenty of examples of inconsistencies with PSA grading and re-submissions getting different grades.