[Archive]

Posted By: scgaynor

Just for the sake of conversation.

I seem to remember both of you participating in a thread about how the 1869 Peck and Snyder CDV of the Cincy Reds should be one of, if not the 1st inductee, into a "Baseball Card Hall of Fame".

My question is, why, if the 1869 CDV is considered a "card" would this Baseball Magazine premium not be considered a "card". There are several Baseball Card issues that have the same "feel" as these Baseball Magazine premiums, but are considered "cards".

My opinion is that neither should fall into the category of "Baseball Card". One is simply a CDV (or even Trade Card), and the other is more like a poster.

Scott