Posted By:
Dan MathewsonI collect only Matty cards, but I do have a few that are favorites...
A Nadja Caramels that I recently picked up.
A 1913 Fan For a Fan.
A couple PSA-8 T206 White Borders.
I have both Sporting Life M-116's (the pastel is an 8, the blue is a 5). I love the depictions of Matty on these...visually one of my favorite cards.
(2) PSA-5 1951 Connie Mack All-Stars (cool cards if you can find ones that aren't punched out).
A nice T-205 (7) that has no edge chipping.
I'm outta state, and too relaxed to remember everything, but these are a few that I really like. But, like Ty-C says, we always seem to want the ones we don't have yet. Like the Breisch Williams, several of the rare Cigarette maker backs, and so on. And, that makes the collecting way fun, Bro.
Awesome thread, and Welcome to the Board! 
-dan