Posted By:
Bruce MorelandIf he says he'll do something he should do it, rather than making you take a loss on the card. He's not out anything if he refunds your money, and you are out a lot if you have to eat a trimmed card.
It is possible that he's telling the truth about it being in a PSA-7 slab at one point. I popped a card out of a PSA slab, sent it in to Beckett, didn't like the grade I got, and sent it back to PSA, and they said it was trimmed. So I know it's possible.
I hope you get your money back though.
bruce