[Archive]

Posted By: Brian Hodes

Actually my understanding is that the cards you describe are OK so long as they have the Goodwin line at the bottom -- size does vary considerably in this set. That said I would defer to some of the serious Old Judge mavens who frequent the Board (i.e. Jay).
Assuming the graders you are talking about are SGC/PSA or GAI I think based on the graded Old Judges that I have seen that are aware of this and would probably not just reject the smaller card.