Posted By:
Brian H This is an interesting site I stumbled across that attempts to rate baseball greats al la "Survivor". The players do not vote each other off (otherwise Ty Cobb would have been among the first to go). Rather, some SABRE experts do the voting based on "greatness" or something along those lines.
I was amazed to see how highly Barry Bonds is regarded by these historian types.
I would rate him 4th or 5th and I'm told that's generous.
Anyway, check it out:
http://www.concentric.net/~jkubatko/baseballsurvivor/voting.html