Here is one possible arrangement:
(forum pic max is 18 so I didn't include 1954 nor 1974)
1954 - Yogi Berra
1955 - Jackie Robinson
1956 - Roberto Clemente
1957 - Ted Williams
1958 - Al Kaline
1959 - Sandy Koufax
1960 - Stan Musial
1961 - Carl Yastrzemski (not his RC)
1962 - Warren Spahn
1963 - Eddie Mathews
1964 - Bob Gibson
1965 - Mickey Mantle
1966 - Hank Aaron
1967 - Willie Mays
1968 - Tom Seaver (not his RC)
1969 - Ernie Banks
1970 - Frank Robinson
1972 - Joe Morgan
1973 - Johnny Bench
1974 - Mike Schmidt