Personally I think Greenberg is extremely undervalued. He has a career OPS over 1.000 and a career OPS+ of 159 while missing his monster prime years.
I think the 19th century HOFers in the Old Judge set are over valued. The OJ set will always have a wow factor because of its age and size, but the players just weren't very good all things considered. I can believe that Hoss Radbourn was the elite pitcher of his time, but anyone winning 60 games in a season isn't playing a game we would recognize.
|