I’m interested to hear what folks have to say. I’m no expert (at all!), but as a Giants collector, I’ve seen a bunch of Mays autographs. This one just looks a bit “off” to me in the “Willie,” but on the other hand, the “smoothness” looks real good. Just my two cents. My opinion means nothing. Although I don’t trust the TPA’s at all, I guess their opinions do, when it comes to selling.
edit: that said, I’m going to say (guess) the Mays is good.