I'd take A over B. The peaks of Ruth, Mantle, and Williams are better overall. Between the three we have a triple crown, a .400 hitter, and a guy who hit more homers than most teams.
Having Bonds as an option seems very odd because of the steroids. Who knows how good Bonds was without knowing how long he took steroids and what effect they truly had.
How about outfield C: Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker, and Stan Musial? I'd take that one over your choice B.
|