Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
It's a holder. Big deal. If SGC hadn't graded it FIVE grades low I wouldn't even have submitted it. Amazing to me the focus of this thread has become the PSA slab, not the fact that SGC has no clue and gave me a 4 on a mint card.
|
It's almost always going to be the other way. The lower grade is usually the more accurate one and the higher one missed something. SGC didn't pull a number out of a hat. The grader clearly saw something. Whether what they saw justifies the grade is up for debate. But unfortunately, we don't get to find out what they saw. We have to guess, look at scans, or take your word for it. Ultimately, we don't have enough information to know which company is clueless.