Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
For what purpose are you picking the team? To win one game? For a season? The next 10 years? Are you picking him at his peak? At the average of his 5 year peak? At a level that would be representative of his overall career? Your hypo doesn't mean anything unless you define your terms? 1973 Ryan? 1993 Ryan? Somewhere in between?
|
Doesn't that sort of highlight the point that James' list might need a bit more nuance before you can claim it means what you claim it must mean?