[Seven]

Interesting discussion so far, gentlemen. I certainly think you can't go wrong, either way but I'm a little more partial to A. Was thinking about throwing in a curveball and having one of the outfields have a player like Oscar Charleston, but I decided to limit it to just players from the MLB

Though I suppose somewhere there's an Outfield C floating around consisting of Speaker, Cobb and Shoeless Joe. Would probably make the choice even more difficult!