Fascinating discussion, as usual.
What about
Paul Waner?
Fielding % as RF
1926 NL .975 (2nd)
1927 NL .980 (1st)
1928 NL .974 (2nd)
1929 NL .985 (1st)
1930 NL .960 (5th)
1931 NL .975 (1st)
1932 NL .971 (2nd)
1933 NL .980 (4th)
1934 NL .983 (1st)
1935 NL .981 (2nd)
1937 NL .969 (4th)
1938 NL .975 (3rd)
1939 NL .975 (2nd)
And also...
H 3152
BA .333
R 1627
RBI 1309
OBP .404
SLG .473
OPS .878
OPS+ 134
