[JollyElm]

My two cents:

I would definitely take the 'under' on the pic to the left (ball in air) and the 'over' on the image to the right, with regards to whether or not it is 'Shoeless' Joe.

The former could really be anyone. His contorted face could be shoehorned to look a bit like Joe Jackson, but I highly doubt that's him. The latter seems to show someone who is much more likely to be him...but could still possibly be someone else who has a similar look to JJ.