Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark17
I went with Bench because, in my opinion, he's the only guy alive who is probably the greatest player at his position.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
Schmidt.
|
I also believe those two were the greatest ever at their positions.
IMO, As far as Bonds is concerned, BEFORE he started cheating, he was certainly one of the two best active players along with Ken Griffey, Jr.
He had as many advantages as anyone and didn't have to suffer to attain like those who came before...he stood on their shoulders and never seemed to be thankful...he just got greedy and took the easy way...same as Clemens.
Though it is not truly relevant to the 'Living GOAT' discussions, the fact that both Bonds and Clemens are absolute jerks (along with Rose) does enter into our choices.
I'll stick with Bench
honorable mentions go to Schmidt and Henderson.
.