I just got back an order from PSA that was a real head scratcher. I got a 6 on a card that was at least a 7. No big surprise. But I also got a 3 on a card that I expected to get an “A” and should never in a million years graded higher than a 2. They are so inconsistent. Nobody really knows what to do with mid grade vintage. I remember hearing Peter at SGC interviewed a couple of years ago and he said (paraphrasing) that their graders will almost always land on the exact same grade for a given card. Such complete nonsense. There are 3s that should be in 5 holders. There are 3s that should be in 1.5 holders. Etc.
|