Interesting test cases over at Heritage closing tonight.
There's a BGS 4.5 Addie Joss selling well above its estimate. As usual, PSA's grade (based on my experience) would be much lower due to corner wear. However, unlike most, it seems to have no tiny tears or nicks or creases so my guess would be (an unfairly harsh) PSA 2--if scan is accurate. Still, the current bids there are in line with that potential re-grading but we'll see where it ends up.
The Joe Jackson appears--to me--to be a rare case where the BGS grade would be pretty much in line with PSA. It's pretty clean and, in fact, looks superior to the Joss. It may be that BGS is tightening up its grading or, more likely, I am missing something in the scans. But this could get the same grade from PSA, almost a first on these...but again, will be interesting to see where price winds up...
https://www.net54baseball.com/attach...1&d=1696017338