[cgjackson222]

Originally Posted by rats60

For #1 I am going with Ty Cobb

Yes! Ty Cobb accounted for over 30% of his team's Runs a record 5 times, with the highest being 32.39% in 1917.

For #2 Honus Wagner in 1908 accounted for 34% of his team's runs. Nate Colbert in 1972 accounted for 33%. Those surely have to be two of the top 5.

Correct! Honus Wagner accounted for 34% of the Pirate's 585 Runs in 1908. That is the highest single season total I have seen.

Babe Ruth accounted for 33.16% of the Red Sox's 564 Runs in 1919, good for the 2nd highest ever.

Nate Colbert accounted for 32.79% of the Padres' 485 Runs in 1972, good for 3rd highest ever.

As previously mentioned, Ty Cobb's high was 32.39%, good for 5th best.

4th place on the list is tricky. Hint: he is not in the Hall Fame, and achieved his feat in the mid-1930s.