Quote:
Originally Posted by packs
It’s not just me who thinks Mattingly was better. That’s what that means.
|
Your reading comprehension skills are apparently very poor if your takeaway from the Posnanksi article was that many people think Mattingly deserves to be in. He is saying a lot more than that. Mainly that Hernandez is more deserving than Mattingly DESPITE what people like you think. Note that this article was part of a
larger series of articles in which Posnanski ranks the best players not in the HOF. Where does he rank Hernandez? Number 22, behind players such as Albert Pujols and ahead of Fred McGriff, Johan Santana, Curt Schilling and Jeff Kent. And where does he rank Mattingly? He ranks him number 53.
Now is the part when Greg G1911 accuses me of "appealing to authority"