Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
And he ranks 95th by JAWS overall. I don't think people will ever agree how to value guys who had short but very high peaks.
|
Koufax ranks ahead of 15 HOF pitchers in JAWS.
Mattingly ranks ahead of 2 HOF 1B in JAWS--Jim Bottomley and George Kelly (arguably the worst member of the HOF).
And to compare Koufax's 5 straight ERA titles and 3 triple crowns to anything accomplished by Mattingly is a stretch at best.