John:
You were 100% correct. I finally had a chance to take a closer look at the back of the actual card. A number of horizontal surface wrinkles, certainly enough to cause a 1.5 grade aside from the miscut. None of these are visible from the front of the card. I stand corrected, PSA got the grade right. SGC, not so much, these certainly do not eliminate an SGC 1 from being given, still no way that I agree with their assessment.
|