Maybe I didn’t explain my question clearly enough. I agree with everyone that the Clemente card is in better condition than the Mantle card. I want to know what justification that SGC has for the unwillingness to give the Mantle card a numerical grade at all. It’s not as far off-center on any border as the Clemente.
In my opinion, if I submit that Clemente to either PSA or SGC, it comes back unholdered by both because it is miscut too badly. I would love to know who the submitter was to SGC on that Clemente card. My guess is that it’s a major one. Otherwise, SGC is 1,000% dead wrong for not crossing my Mantle card to at least a 1. In my opinion, should be more like a 1.5 or 2 but giving it the benefit of the doubt here.
|