Quote:
Originally Posted by G1911
The card is significantly short beyond natural variance, in both directions. That should be disclosed.
You said you didn’t know what more they could do. What they could do is list it honestly after being informed.
I don’t think it’s okay to list an altered card without noting it, but refunding the buyer if they catch it and ask for one because you didn’t disclose the truth, just like Jaimet. The Will Jaimet standard is not a good one and nobody could really defend it.
|
The seller, who I assume has the card in hand, doesn't think it's trimmed.
There are a number of people who think it is trimmed based on the picture, which were posted by the seller.
In my opinion, Will Jaimet is not a valid analogy to the seller.
This will be my final post on this thread, because you and I are having a conversation similar to those had on the death penalty or abortion or whether Trump was/is an asshole, neither of us is "wrong".
I respect your opinion (far more than those of the opinion sellers), and hope that you use that opinion to not purchase the card.
Best regards,
Doug "I wish I was trimmed" Goodman