A hard question to answer.
Over the years I've drifted between wanting nice cards to wanting more cards and back.
I'm also in my occasional "who would pay that much for a common?" phase which comes up right after every major price increase.
Quick answer,
I'd get the Brown because I already have a Willett.
Complicated answer,
Over time, the brown will probably appreciate more. Unless the hobby drifts away from collecting star players and towards better preserved examples no matter who is on them (Don't hold your breath waiting for that....)
But it does come down to which you'd personally enjoy more.
|