[ALR-bishop]

How can the repack story be hokey if they are admittedly cards obtained by a 3d party at some point and repackaged....which they obviously are. And they are "real" Topps cards, right ?

I have no idea when they were first offered. That is what I want to know. Personal curiosity. Murphy first offered his around 2001. Justin--you say you saw them in the early 80s. Were they Christmas packs or something else ? That would be a new fact for me

Ben says he saw them K Mart in the 1980s. You don't believe him ? Others have posted in other threads they think they bought them in the 80s at retail, but could not recall where. Agree you would think there would be more first hand accounts if they were sold at any large retail stores.

No one I am aware of has said they were a 50s product. In numerous threads over time I have seen reference to repacking in the 60s and 70s, but with no concrete evidence or first hand knowledge, That's what I want to know. When did they ( Christmas racks) first appear ? who started them ? When and where, if anywhere, were they sold at retail ? Just hobby curiosity.

And they are not garbage. They are real Topps cards in plainly visible condition, usually mid range.

Agreed they are not a Topps product and not mint cards

Do not understand why people get so upset about them. If someone buys them thinking they are something other than repackaged already circulated cards then that is another issue about the buyers. I am just interested in the actual history of these things. But you already know I am weird, I collect recurring print defects