Barone's makes a decent grandma pie (ask for it well done) and as a bonus is in the restaurant where they shot the date scene in
Fast Times At Ridgemont High, when it was a restaurant called The Matterhorn Chef.
We used to go to Barone's all the time, until Mulberry Street opened.
Best pizza I ever had was in NYC at Rocky Lee's Chu Cho Bianco (RIP).
Sinatra used to order his from there when he was in town. Right up there as well was Mimi's on Lexington between 84th and 85th (RIP).
Bobby Flay got his start working there and it was Paul McCartneys go-to pie. My daughter lives in the village and likes John's on Bleecker St. I like that too but it is too much of a rugby scrum to order. I want a slice, not an elbow in the kidneys.