Quote:
Originally Posted by G1911
Nobody thinks in such absolutes without any regard for context whatsoever.
A person who is pro-life does not believe that there is no such thing as justifiable self-defense and that they are obligated to let their family be killed instead, or that the innocent and the guilty are the exact same thing.
A person who is pro-choice does not believe anyone can make any choice at any time.
This should not need to be said. I’m sure the two sides could debate on reasonable grounds.
|
Note the logical flaw in his reasoning -- only people who make no exceptions whatsoever can be "true" believers. The "no true Scotsman" fallacy, or a variant, I think. But then he adds to the proposition that anyone who is not a "true" believer is a hypocrite. Geez.