1. Big Ed Delahanty
2. Buck Ewing
3. Roger Connor
4. Sam Thompson
5. Billy Hamilton
UN- honorable mention Cap Anson.
Honorable mention George Wright.
BTW if Ed Delahanty is not on your list go look at his stat line and do some research of his dominance at the plate.
https://sabr.org/gamesproj/game/july...home-run-game/