All LEGIT Nodgrass print errors have a partial part of the right side of the 'S' still present.
There was a gent about 20 years ago in PA who was removing the S off and PSA was grading them until we figured it out. There were even a few catching poses that got slabbed by PSA at the time.
Sadly the dummy didn't do his homework first and removed the entire 'S' and off of catching poses too which is a separate run and impossible.
The die broke and part of the 'S' remained for several print runs of the batting pose.
If the card was raw, you could easily tell by tilting it under a lamp and you would see a dull circle where the 'S' once resided.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/36376001233...2Cchnl%3Dmkcid
Dan Mckee