Quote:
Originally Posted by hcv123
1) On a good day the grading companies are inconsistent and on a bad day bordering on incompetent. I can't tell you how many stories I've heard of people cracking and resubmitting - getting the same card back within a 3 grade range!! If you are REALLY good I would say you should be able to consistently land within a 1 grade deviation. Depending what you collect, that could represent some significant price differences, I just don't think it is realistic to get any better than that.
2) Have seemingly changed their standards over the years. Today's "7" looks very different from a 7 graded 15 years ago (with plenty of exceptions)
Tools - DEFINITELY a 10x lighted loupe. A blacklight. sample cards from the years you are looking at to check for sizing.
|
Thanks Howard... yeah, I'd settle to be within 1 grade of actual/received. I'll admit that I have sent in some newer cards (80's rookies, Mattingly, Strawberry, Sandberg) pretty certain they were very high grades and they came back with a big miss (by me).
Total waste of $$.
I've gotten better but I'm not sure I'm a +/- 1 grade DIY expert yet - at least not reliably.
Is this something this forum has ever considered - would we ever "crowd source" grade estimates for each other to see if we can save each other the time/cost to submit? Could get unwieldy, I suppose.
It feels like there may be some way to community-pre-grade somehow.
I'll keep try to learn myself as well.
Thanks again -
Jeff