Yes, seen play is a tough one. So many great players between 74 and now (Or for me a few years ago, the Sox have been an expensive ticket.
I'd have to give sort of an honorable mention to Hank Aaron. I went to a game in 76 on a church trip and he was there, but didn't play in that game.
The usual suspects for the Red Sox, Yaz, Rice, Lynn, Clemens, Boggs, Ortiz, Pedro...
I haven't been to many hockey or Basketball games, but did get to see Havliceks last game, which got rescheduled from the collapsed Hartford Civic Center to the last game of the year at the old Garden.
I haven't made it to any pro football games, but did go to Army-Navy four times.
The best player I ever met? I'll call it a tie, although by stats it's not really close. Bob Feller who I got to sit with for a while at a minor league doubleheader in I think 75? And Brooks Robinson who I met at a SI hospitality suite in 76. (which I was WAY underage for, but sometimes the rules have to be set aside. Thanks Dad!
)