I would go with choice 3, Too Random.
Think about how different the HOF would be if we started over, and used actual reasoned analysis instead of politics and myth.
This is an institution that elected Tinker-Evers-Chance simultaneously because they were in a famous poem, Mazeroski based mainly on a single home run and Bruce Sutter despite a fWAR of 19.2.
Lou Whitaker has a higher fWAR than fellow Tigers Jack Morris and Alan Trammell, and more than double the fWAR than fellow 2B Mazeroski. Yet he's not in. I just don't see any rationality in Mazeroski being in and Whitaker out.
So I've given up. I just don't care, because it's simply too random to be valid, IMO.
|