Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
For sure, but I think at least in theory there is room for an argument that a guy who clearly had a HOF career pre stuff is deserving.
|
So if Pete Rose didn't bet on games until he passed Ty Cobb, is he deserving?
Personally, I don't buy that argument. But I also can't exclude anyone from the HOF who is on the ballot. That's telling me that MLB and the HOF both believe that they are eligible. As opposed to Pete or Shoeless Joe, who are not on the eligible list. If MLB or the HOF don't want them in the HOF, then suspend them from baseball and take them off the ballot. Stand up and make a decision MLB and HOF. It's the same no-show of leadership that Selig practiced his entire tenure as Commish.