Quote:
Originally Posted by STL1944
I recently discovered that one of my PSA cards of Hugh "Fireman" Casey graded as a PSA 8 is probably trimmed (see photo's below for specifics).
My gut is to get my other copy graded, keep the PSA 8 but pull it out of the registry to be fair to others.
|
Well, I have a few thoughts -
1 - "probably"? Ok, sure.
2 - Based on what a great job they did grading your "8", you should get a "12" on your raw one, so I would absolutely pay them for their opinion on it.
3 - Since your "8" is really trimmed on three sides, which makes it "really" worth less than the fee they will charge for the next opinion you pay them for, what you SHOULD do, is bust it out of the case and thumbtack it to your wall, as a reminder to be more careful about future purchases. OR. You could try to sell it to the guy who owns the Diamondbacks, my understanding is that he pays well for trimmed cards.
Doug "honesty is my only excuse" Goodman