Quote:
Originally Posted by rats60
Low run environment is irrelevant when caused by superior pitching. Same for park affect when you choose to ignore Koufax's 4 years in the LA Coliseum.
|
The only sensible way to look at ERA is to compare a pitcher to his peers. That accounts for general trends in ballparks, juiced baseballs, mound height, league expansion, etc.
Koufax led the league in ERA 5 times. Pretty impressive. Grove led the league in ERA 9 times. More impressive.
You can't win these arguments, Koufax vs Grove:
Best season - Grove's 1931 is insane. The 3 guys to win 30 games since 1920 are Grove (31 in 1931), Dean (30 in 1934), and McLain (31 in 1968.) Despite Grove and Dean doing it in a 154 game season, and players since 1961 having 8 more games, it hasn't been done in the last 50+ years.
Best run of 6 consecutive seasons: Grove, see above.
Career:
ERA titles: Koufax 5, Grove 9
Wins: Koufax 165, Grove 300
Win percentage: Koufax 65%, Grove 68% (highest among 300 game winners and eighth best overall).
Short term (one season), Grove.
Best years (6 season run), Grove.
Career, Grove.
We remember Koufax. Many of us saw him in his prime. He is a very popular player and fellow.
Grove was better, period.