Quote:
	
	
		
			
				
					Originally Posted by  Gary Dunaier
					 
				 
				It IS conceivable that a man could give his grandson a '52 Mantle that he knows to be a reprint, and many years later, the kid, who grows up to be a person of less than sterling ethics, puts it up for sale and says "my grandfather gave it to me" - which, in the case of this hypothetical example, would be true. 
			
		 | 
	
	
 If the seller is 11 years old, his grandfather could've given it to him last month.
What is deceptive is the part of the listing that says Manufacturer: Topps.  Topps didn't make that card.