Hi Todd. I do agree with you that both Domino Disc variations are of Doc and not Frank.
According to Baseball Reference in December 1911 Doc was traded from the Brooklyn Dodgers to the Philadelphia Phillies for Eddie Stack. Although it looks like 1911 was Doc's last season and he never actually played for the Phillies.
The Baseball Encyclopedia 9th Edition 1993 doesn't show Doc's 1911 trade to the Phillies (see pics below).
I still think that the correct spelling is Scanlan though. At least according to MLB, Baseball Reference & Baseball Almanac it is.
I added a few additional websites below for viewing.
William "Doc" Scanlan
MLB
Baseball Reference
Baseball Almanac
Greater Syracuse Sports Hall Of Fame
Frank Scanlan
MLB
Baseball Reference
Baseball Almanac
__________________
"Baseball was one-hundred percent of my life." - Ty Cobb
"Baseball was, is and always will be to me the best game in the world." - Babe Ruth
"Baseball is the only thing I know." - Rogers Hornsby
Wanted:
updated March 3, 2024
Detroit Tigers American Caramel & National Caramel
For sale or trade
updated October 24, 2018