Regardless of how subjective things could possibly get between different graders at any of the big 3, you'd like to have at least some sense of consistency that you can loosely rely on (scandal aside).
At times I want to think that's sometimes the case. Then you see something like this....
I have a '55 T Jackie Robinson that looks like a 6 on the front. A light crease halfway down the back. PSA gave it a 2. I'm thinking, ok, it has a crease somewhere, it got a 2.
Then I see this today:
How on earth....a 3.5 by comparison? The crease along the upper right part of the card is even more pronounced zooming in. Then whatever is going on in the bottom right. Corners mediocre. 70/30 L/R. Can't even see the back so it might even get worse.
I don't get it.