Quote:
Originally Posted by benjulmag
Bob, as to your question whether PWCC ultimately decides to invoke the PSA grading guaranty and seek reimbursement from PSA, I think they would have a lot of trouble doing that. The guaranty proscribes the original submitter from invoking it. So to the extent that the cards at issue were cards Moser bought from PWCC and then had PWCC submit for grading, by the technical wording of the guaranty, PWCC would be out of luck. If Moser on the other hand was the person who submitted them to PSA, I suspect PSA would still resist payment arguing that PWCC and Moser were in cahoots over the doctoring scheme and therefore should be legally regarded as one and the same.
|
The reason I mentioned and asked that was because I don't believe the general public knows for certain yet how and by whom all those altered cards were originally submittted to PSA, is that not correct? I imagine some could have been submitted by PWCC, some by Moser directly, as well as others maybe being submitted by different "friends and family" of the parties involved. I agree with your thinking, PSA would not follow the warranty for someone they felt was actually submitting the altered cards, or that they felt was involved in the scheme.
Think about this though, as a possible way PWCC could still recoup some monies from this fiasco they are in the middle of. They end up buying back these altered cards sold and simply break them out of the PSA holders. They then sell/transfer them to someone, say a "friend" to disseminate back into the market place who sells them raw, and then say whomever gets them goes ahead and submits them to PSA thinking they may have gotten a real deal/steal. PWCC gets at least some of their money back, the cards are no longer in a PSA holder attributed to their previous ownership/handling, so harder to track back and blame them for. The person who ends up buying one/more of these now raw cards, and then submits them to PSA for grading, could actually be an honest, innocent collector just looking to get a card they felt they got a good deal on, graded. And then lets say PSA (or any of the other TPGs) gets fooled again and gives the card(s) a numerical grade. Now they are still out there circulating in the hobby and not so easily tracked back and blamed on PWCC and Moser. Not sure what you can do to insure these cards never get recirculated back into the hobby, unless the TPGs can figure out a better way/process to detect and report when these cards are altered.