When I saw the title of this thread I thought it was going to be a joke. Someone just trying to lighten the mood. I figured who would bring up this subject with all that's currently going on? But I was wrong. My biggest surprise is how little reaction this thread is getting. Everyone is so ready to out the card doctors, but lets start a thread that shows a better way you can flatten cards at home. Are you serious? Am I the only one getting confused about what is and what is not acceptable? Where do collectors stand on this issue? It seems like there are very mixed messages. It's okay to soak your cards, smash them flat, erase marks with an artist eraser, all in the name of making them look better. That's okay, you didn't modify it, you only took away things that weren't supposed to be there. Hmm... I'm beginning to think there are 1000's of card doctors out there. You might only have to look in a mirror. Everyone who has soaked a bunch of cards out of a scrapbook, everyone who has erased prices off the back of a card, everyone who has spooned out a crease or flattened back down a corner, is a card doctor.
Maybe you only did it once or twice, maybe you justified it because it's just for your own collection, but let's at least be honest. This has been going on FOR YEARS! Are we just now noticing? Seriously? I argued that I felt soaking a card with water is the same as soaking it with a chemical. We even discussed whether water was a chemical. Do you remember? How many said soaking cards is fine? Most collectors here thought it was perfectly okay. I'm not even sure I'm against it, it's undoubtedly how we've gotten most of the high grade tobacco and caramel cards. But let's at least admit what's going on. You're taking a card, getting it wet, and smashing it flat with a pile of weights/books (or clamps if you follow the new method). Do you think that might have removed some creases at the same time? If I'm following the argument correctly, the only things that are considered taboo are trimming a card or adding color. Some people don't want you to soak it in a chemical, but many even said that is okay if it doesn't smell "like chemicals" when you are done. I can't make this stuff up.
Okay, back to bashing the real card doctors.
|